FSH Watch
Vol. 1 No. 2, Fall 1994
A publication of the FacioScapuloHumeral Society
Provided by the
FSH Society, Inc.
Inside ...
Organizations Vie for a Sliver of the Budget Pie
In July, 1994, the Associated Press wrote the following article detailing some
of the political maneuvering employed by organizations trying to obtain funding
for medical research. We are running this article to help our membership better
understand the enormous uphill battle we are fighting. Our thanks go to the
Associated Press and writer Alan Fram for their assistance. Used with
permission.
Washington (AP)--Daniel Perez, chief activist for the thousands of
Americans afflicted with the adult form of muscular dystrophy, wants Congress
to target $500,000 for research next year on the degenerative disease. So last
winter, the 32-year-old software designer from Lexington, Mass.--himself
stricken with the disease--got to work. He testified before two
congressional subcommittees for nine minutes, and urged the 550 members of his
FSH Society, named for facioscapulohumeral disease, to contact their senators
and representatives.
"I like to think we're doing the best we can with our
resources," Perez says of his group's $25,000 budget.
When the National Education Association (NEA) wanted to protect federal
education programs, it had a bit more brawn. For the nation's largest
union and one of the biggest congressional campaign contributors, this included
its $170 million budget and a 50-person government relations staff. It also
used its new interactive computer network to prod its 2.2 million members to
visit and write lawmakers.
The teachers' union and Perez focused their efforts on the same bill:
legislation providing $252 billion in 1995 for the departments of Labor, Health
and Human Services, and Education, plus some smaller agencies. They and
hundreds of other schools, unions, patients' groups and others have
spent 1994 in all-out competition, each lobbying for a piece of
Congress' biggest spending measure.
So far, neither Perez nor the NEA is overjoyed. The Senate Appropriations
Committee and the full House have completed separate versions of the
legislation, each slashing several education programs and making no mention of
FSHD. But they typify the groups, big and small, who have sought the ears of
the 27 members of the House and Senate Appropriations Committees'
subcommittees that wrote the measure.
Mirroring the bills' contents, the lobbies are a Who's Who of
popular causes: the National Breast Cancer Coalition, and Reading is
Fundamental among them. That puts a premium on standing out from the crowd, and
in knowing the right people. To accomplish this, many schools and groups work
with experienced Washington lobbyists.
The Coriell Institute for Medical Research of Camden, N.J., is a client of
Cassidy and Associates, a lobbying firm whose staff includes numerous former
congressional staff workers. With its bill, the Senate Appropriations Committee
urges the National Institutes of Health to give "full
consideration" to Coriell's request for money to help it
establish a cell repository.
Another weapon is the folks back home, whose pleas quickly draw
lawmakers' attention. "If local people tell you something that
really makes sense to you, that's the key to it," says Rep.
Neal Smith, D-Iowa, who chairs the House subcommittee.
When President Clinton proposed freezing some aid to the nation's
research universities in February, scores of schools snapped into action. In a
campaign coordinated by the Association of American Universities, they begged
their senators and representatives to head off the plan. Included was the
University of Iowa, whose officials met with Smith and Sen. Tom Harkin, another
Iowa Democrat who chairs the Senate subcommittee. "Both were receptive
to the problems we raised," said Derek Willard, the
university's associate vice president for research. In the end, both
Smith's and Harkin's bills ignored Clinton's
proposal to freeze the assistance, though both left room for future changes in
the money's distribution.
Another attention-getting technique is campaign contributions, which
organizations hope will help re-elect sympathetic lawmakers and gain them
access. The NEA contributed $391,000 to House and Senate candidates last year,
including $500 to $1,000 to each of the eight Democrats on Smith's
appropriations subcommittee, according to the nonpartisan Center for Responsive
Politics. Other frequent contributors to subcommittee members include unions
and groups representing doctors and health professionals.
For others, the subcommittees' public hearings, held before the bills
are written, are a chance to be heard. Each panel heard brief testimony from
150 groups this year, ranging from the AIDS Action Council to the Women Take
Heart Project. Scores of others wanted to appear; to pick its 150, the House
panel held a lottery by computer.
To stand out, some groups flash celebrities. The actress Mary Tyler Moore, who
has diabetes, testifies frequently for the Juvenile Diabetes Foundation; Chris
Burke, an actor with Down Syndrome, spoke for the National Down Syndrome
Society. "That gets the cameras there, and it gets the members
there," said Smith, a 28-year veteran of the process.
Some disease groups send patients to testify, most touchingly children or the
parents of afflicted youngsters. "The doctors told my parents I would
never live for over a week, but I did," 8th-grader Brianne Schwantes,
who has a bone disease, told Smith's panel in February. Many lawmakers
find that sort of testimony most memorable, no matter how often
they've heard it.
--Alan Fram, Associated Press Writer
v v v
From the President
The first edition of the FSH Watch was well received and we are pleased to
present this second edition. It is our hope to be able to continue to provide
quality information that is both useful and timely.
I am writing to you today on matters of concern to thousands of families
affected with facioscapulohumeral disease. When I founded the FSH Society three
years ago, I was seriously concerned about the lack of organization in the FSHD
community as a whole, and the need to work with the FSHD research community. I
stand firmly on that belief today.
The FSH Society was created out of a sincere concern for the community of
individuals living with FSHD. The information presented in this newsletter is
collected with a deep commitment and a sense of responsibility to individuals
involved with FSHD. I know that each of you receiving this information will
reciprocate with a sense of commitment and responsibility to the FSH Society.
Please realize that all the programs being developed, and efforts represented,
are made by people who manage, as you do, within the continuing role of FSHD in
the theaters of the mind and body.
With the arrival of autumn, as the days get shorter and the shadows lengthen, I
become keenly aware of the approach of the end of the year. Today, I ask if we
should be pleased with the progress that the FSH Society has made since the
first of the year? The answer is a resounding yes.
Earlier this year, I testified on behalf of the FSH Society in front of both
Houses of Congress. We also submitted several well researched written
testimonies outlining a plan of action for the federal government on FSHD
research. In 1994, the Society met with the National Institutes of Health (NIH)
four times. The United States Public Health Service has expressed a healthy
interest and a sincere concern about FSHD. In fact, even though Congress did
not make any mention of FSHD in the congressional budget this year, the
National Institute of Arthritis and Musculoskelatal Diseases (NIAMS) granted a
directly titled NIH grant for molecular genetics research on FSHD.
In addition, NIH has expressed an interest in supporting, in part, a joint FSH
Society/NIH scientific symposium on FSHD research in early 1996. The cost of a
scientific symposium is between $40,000 and $60,000. We are setting up a
special "Research & Education Fund" to earmark funds towards
this conference. Please consider making a donation or asking others to make a
donation to this fund. We need to raise these funds to support the symposium in
1996.
The Society has conducted all of its organizational business, met the 1994
budget, published two newsletters, done several national mailings, formed new
support groups, increased its membership substantially, provided two offices
for people to call for information, and continues to create new and innovative
programs for FSHD.
As 1994 draws to a close, we need you. We need people with expertise in fund
raising and grant writing. We need politicians with direct experience with FSHD
to provide us with a patient/congress intersection. We need substantial
corporate support. We need people to get involved by responding to the
information and questions presented in this newsletter. Lastly, we need you to
consider making a 1994 tax deductible donation and to become a member in
1995.
It can be said that in 1994 the FSH Society changed the FSHD landscape
significantly by providing information, networking and advocacy. We look to
1995 as the year in which one or more FSHD genes will be identified. We hope
that 1995 will be the year in which the FSH Society will be there to help you
manage your way to health.
--Daniel Paul Perez, President
FacioScapuloHumeral Society
Acknowledgements
In Honor of Jessica Ryley
Carolyn Jo Chesney - Florida
Martin and Mary E. Doto - New York
Jo Ann Frye - Georgia
Rick Frye - Washington
Thomas M. Frye - Tennessee
Thelma Green - Michigan
Pamela L. Pappas - Maryland
James Ryley, Jr. - Pennsylvania
Mr. and Mrs. Mary Ryley - Ohio
David D. Smith - Ohio
Mrs. Joanne Smith - Michigan
Timothy J. Smith - Texas
In Memory of
Jerome V. Lusson
Ralph and Helen Amos - Illinois
Dorothea Blohm - Illinois
J. L. Brady Co. - Illinois
Dale A. and Margaret Scudder Brchan - Minnesota
Robert and Maryanna Claxton - Minnesota
Francis and Margaret Coene - Illinois
Fred and Helen DeCoster - Illinois
Mr. and Mrs. Donald S. Fenton - Illinois
John Deere Company - North Carolina
Arlo and Marie Hasselbusch - Illinois
Denise Hawley - Iowa
Mr. and Mrs. Delbert Hoyle - Illinois
Mrs. Evelyn I. Lusson - Arizona
Charles R. McNally - Oregon
Carol J. Perry - Nebraska
Myrtle M. Pratt - Arizona
Rock River Plumbing - Mechanical Contractors Assn., Inc. - Illinois
Lawrence A. Ross - Indiana
Friends from "The Boulders" - Arizona
Mr. & Mrs. Bernard Tremblay
Mr. and Mrs. Lawrence Van de Kerckhove - Illinois
Homer and Elsie VanMeter - Illinois
Members
Claudine H. Brown - New Mexico
Brian Luoma - Minnesota
Robert A. Olds - Maryland
Dabney Richey - Texas
Gloria Richmond - Massachusetts
David O. Smith - Ohio
Contributors
John L. DeFranzo & Son Contracting & Trucking - Massachusetts
I.R.I - Massachusetts - Employees 1994 Lottery/Auction Charity
Mildren Lauretano - Massachusetts In honor of her sister Gloria Richmond
and her niece, Ann Starkey
Donald C. Lokerson - Maryland In honor of Karen Johnsen's work
with the Mid Atlantic FSHD Support Group
Reba Battery Company - Colorado
Diana Sitkowski - Massachusetts In honor of her friends, Gloria Richmond
and Ann Starkey
Condolences
The FSH Society extends it condolences to the family of Jerome V. Lusson. Mr.
Lusson, a dedicated member of the FSH Society, died on July 31, 1994. The FSH
Society expresses appreciation to the Lusson family and his wife, Evelyn I.
Lusson, for establishing the Jerome V. Lusson memorial fund, and to the friends
and family who have honored his memory.
The FSH Watch is published by the FSH Society and distributed, by mail, to its
members and supporters. To be placed on the mailing list or to submit an
article please write to: Daniel Perez, FSH Society, 3 Westwood Road, Lexington,
MA 02420. Articles may be edited for space and clarity. Every effort has been
made to ensure accuracy in the newsletter. If you wish to correct an error,
please write to the above address.
High Protein and Exercise Therapy (HPET) in
FacioScapuloHumeral (FSHD) Muscular Dystrophy
Subjects Needed for New Study
A collaborative study into the effect of nutrition and exercise in
FacioScapuloHumeral (FSHD) Muscular Dystrophy is under way between the muscle
centers at North Shore University Hospital in New York, and Massachusetts
General Hospital and Brigham & Women's Hospital in Boston,
Massachusetts under the direction of Alfred E. Slonim, M.D.; Barbara E.
Shapiro, M.D., Ph.D.; and David C. Preston, M.D. respectively. For the past 12
years, Dr. Slonim has been involved in the investigation and treatment of
various muscular dystrophies, and particularly the metabolic myopathies. Dr.
Slonim has been primarily involved in the clinical research study of these
disorders, devising therapeutic techniques and examining the effect of short
term and long term administration of different nutritional substrates with and
without submaximal exercise.
All interested patients will be initially screened with a series of questions
by telephone, either at the Massachusetts General Hospital or the Brigham and
Women's Hospital. After the telephone interview, you will be evaluated
in the MDA clinic by Dr. Shapiro or Dr. Preston. It is important to bring
copies of your medical records to the initial visit. A clinical examination
will be performed and laboratory blood and urine tests obtained. If you have
not been thoroughly investigated in the past, further studies including nerve
conduction studies, EMG and muscle biopsy may be performed.
After the initial evaluation, you will be scheduled for a muscle strength test.
In addition, you will be scheduled to meet with the physical therapist who will
instruct you in aerobic submaximal exercise, and an individually designed
exercise program will be established. Testing will include videotaping and
timing of several functional activities, such as walking, and arising from a
chair. Two pulmonary function tests will be performed.
You will also meet with the nutritionist who will perform an initial dietary
evaluation and instruct you on the diet. If possible, you will be seen every
two weeks for the first two months, monthly for the next four months, and then
every two months for the next six months. Three-day food records will be
obtained to assess dietary compliance with energy and protein recommendations
and to determine adequacy of nutrient intake. Weight and height will be
monitored. The nutritionist will confer with the M.D. to modify meal plans as
warranted. The high protein diet consists of three meals and three snacks a day
so that high circulating amino acids should be available to the working muscles
throughout the day. Supplementing the diet with protein is achieved by
increasing dietary protein during the meals, and drinking a high protein milk
shake consisting of ProMod and skim milk as a snack between meals.
If you are interested in participating in the study, or have further questions,
please contact Dr. Shapiro at (617) 724-3914 or Dr. Preston at (617)
732-5406.
MDA Research Portfolio
The following is a listing of the 1993 Muscular Dystrophy Association research
portfolio for FSHD. This information was obtained by the FSH Society in August,
1994, and may have changed.
Irvine, CA -- University of California
Investigator:Michael R. Altherr, Ph.D.
Title:Cloning the Gene Responsible for FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular
Dystrophy.
Summary:A project aimed at identifying the gene that, when defective, is
responsible for FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular Dystrophy.
Duration:Three years, 10/01/93 - 09/30/96.
Class:Genetic Research Grant.
Iowa City, IA -- University of Iowa
Investigator:Katherine D. Mathews, M.D.
Title:FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular Dystrophy Mapping and Gene Isolation.
Summary:The goal of this project is to locate and identify the defective gene
that causes FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular Dystrophy.
Duration:Three years. 07/01/92 - 06/30/95.
Class:Genetic Research Grant.
Waltham, MA -- Genome Therapeutics, Corp.
Investigator:Barbara Weiffenbach, Ph.D.
Title:Cloning the Gene for FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular Dystrophy (FSHD).
Summary:Study to find the gene that, when defective, causes
FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular Dystrophy.
Duration:Three years 02/01/92 - 01/31/95.
Class:Genetic Research Grant
Rochester, NY -- University of Rochester
Investigator:Michael P. McDermott, Ph.D.
Title:Natural History of FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular Dystrophy.
Summary:Definition of the progression of the disease FacioScapuloHumeral
Muscular Dystrophy in preparation for clinical trials.
Duration:Three years. 01/01/93 - 12/31/95.
Class:Research Grant.
Durham, NC -- Duke University
Investigator:John R. Gilbert, Ph.D.
Title:Mapping the FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular Dystrophy Gene.
Summary:Studies to find the gene that, when defective, results in
FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular Dystrophy, known to be located within a small
region of chromosome 4.
Duration:Three years. 09/01/91 - 08/31/94.
Class:Genetic Research Grant.
Leiden, Netherlands -- University of Leiden
Investigator:Rune R. Frants, Ph.D.
Title:Cloning and Characterization of the FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular
Dystrophy Gene.
Summary:A project focused on isolating and characterizing the
FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular Dystrophy gene on chromosome 4.
Duration:Two years. 01/01/93 - 12/31/94
Class:Genetic Research Grant.
Manchester, England -- Manchester University
Investigator:Jane E. Hewitt, Ph.D.
Title:Mapping of Distal Chromosome 4q35, the FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular
Dystrophy Gene Region.
Summary:A map of the region of chromosome 4 that contains the defective gene
causing FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular Dystrophy will be developed to enable the
identification of the gene.
Duration:Three years. 10/01/93 - 09/30/96.
Class:Genetic Research Grant.
Thank You!
The FSH Society wishes to acknowledge the following for their contributions to
our efforts:
Bev and Jim Weyenberg, Kaukauna, WI for mailing the FSH Watch and letters to
the network members.
Thilmany Division, International Paper, for contributing supplies for our
membership mailing.
Researchers
Tokyo, Japan
Although we still do not know the nature of the FSHD gene and the protein
associated with it, the DNA rearrangements associated with FSHD have been found
to cause a decrease in the size of the EcoRI fragment detected with the p13E-11
and pFR-1 probes, and deletions of the 3.3 kb repeat units within the fragment
are thought to cause the disease. However, we still face diagnostic
uncertainties due to locus hetero geneity, recombination event, and the fact
that the probes detect several loci other than 4q35.
We have examined 158 Japanese individuals, including 38 FSHD patients from 18
families, and found that all but one of the FSHD patients had smaller (<28
kb) EcoRI fragments which co-segregated with the disease. This included
patients who had a severe inflammatory response in muscle, and suggested the
presence of different immune effector mechanisms in FSHD from what have been
described in either Duchenne muscular dystrophy or inflammatory myopathies.
We also found two severely affected patients who had the shortest EcoRI
fragment identified to date that contains no more than one 3.3 kb repeat unit.
This result suggests that the short fragment may provide a means of
understanding the molecular details involved at the site of the chromosomal
rearrangement in FSHD. However, there is an urgent need for more studies to
settle the question as to whether the size of the fragment is actually related
to the severity of the disease.
Nonetheless, we are now entering a new era, and we are beginning to understand
FSHD. We hope that we can find the gene and its product in the not too distant
future. This, in turn, will contribute to genetic counseling and treatment of
the disease.
Kiichi Arahata
Hideo Sugita
J.H. Lee
Department of Neuromuscular Research
National Institute of Neuroscience, NCNP
4-1-1 Ogawa-higashi, Kodiara
Tokyo, 187, Japan
Interest(s): Molecular genetics and clinical
Los Alamos, NM
Michael R. Altherr
Life Sciences
Group LS 2, M880
Los Alamos National Laboratory
Los Alamos, New Mexico 87545
Interest(s): Molecular genetics
This group has developed hybrid cell lines (hamster cells with small pieces of
chromosome 4). These cell line facilitate mapping and isolation of new probes.
Lab is analyzing transcripts in the FSH region.
Waltham, MA
Barbara Weiffenbach
Susan Manning
Ziying Liu
Genome Therapeutics, Corp.
1365 Main Street
Waltham, Massachusetts 02154
Interest(s): Molecular genetics
Paris, France
Michael Fardeau
Institut National de La Sante et
de le Recherche Medicale
17 Rue du Fer-a-Moulin
75005 Paris
France
Interest(s): Clinical
Marburg, West Germany
Manuela Koch
Institut for Humangenetic der Philipps-Universitat
Bahnhofstr. 7A
D-3550 Marburg
West Germany
Interest(s): Molecular genetics
Leiden, Netherlands
Nijmegen, Netherlands
Egbert Bakker presented a poster at the American Society of Human Genetics
meeting held in Montreal in late October 1994 on diagnostic testing for FSHD
individuals within the Netherlands. The presentation stated that the Department
of Human Genetics at Leiden University would be offering diagnostic testing for
FSHD families and sporadic cases. Testing is limited to Dutch families within
the Netherlands.
Oebo F. Brouwer
Department of Neurology
University Hospital Leiden
P.O. Box 9600
2300 RC Leiden
The Netherlands
Rune R. Frantz
Nicole Datson
Judith C.T. van Deutekom
Marten Hofker
Egbert Bakker
Cisca Wijmenga*
Institute for Anthropogenetica
MGC-Department of Human Genetics
Wassenaarseweg 72
2333 AL Leiden,
The Netherlands
George W.A.M. Padberg
University Hospital Nijmegen St Radboud
Department of Neurology
Reinier Postlaan 4
P.O. Box 9101
6500 HB Nijmegen
The Netherlands
Interest(s): Molecular genetics and clinical
*Cisca Wijmenga is currently with The National Center for Human Genome
Research, Laboratory of Gene Transfer, National Institutes of Health, Building
4G, Room 3A14, 9000 Rockville Pike, Bethesda, MD 20892
Rochester, NY
University of Rochester investigators are pursuing two major lines of research
in facioscapulohumeral dystrophy: (1) molecular studies targeted at cloning the
FSHD gene and; (2) clinical studies focusing on developing treatment for
FSHD.
The molecular studies are spearheaded by Denise Figlewicz, Ph.D., in
collaboration with Rabi Tawil, M.D., James Forrester, and Robert C. Griggs,
M.D. Genes close to the 4q telomere are being sought as possible candidates for
the FSHD gene.
The clinical studies, directed by Dr. Rabi Tawil in collaboration with Dr.
Griggs, and with Drs. Jerry Mendell and John Kissel of Ohio State University,
are defining the natural history of FSHD and will make it possible to detect
beneficial effects of treatment trials. Our first treatment trial, using the
corticosteriod prednisone, is well underway. New trials with other agents are
under development.
Robert Griggs
Rabi Tawil
Denise Figlewicz
Lynn Cos
James Forrester
Michael McDermott
University of Rochester School of Medicine
Department of Neurology
601 Elmwood Avenue
P.O. Box 673
Rochester, New York 14642
Interest(s): Molecular genetics and clinical
Durham, NC
Margaret Pericak-Vance
John R. Gilbert
Duke University Medical Center
227D Bryan Research Building
P.O. Box 2900
Durham, North Carolina 27710
Interest(s): Molecular genetics
Iowa City, IA
Katherine Matthews
Brian Shute
Kate Mills
Julie Fedderson
Holly Bailey
Jeff Murray
Department of Pediatrics
216 MRC
University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics
Iowa City, Iowa 52242
Interest(s): Molecular genetics and clinical
Group has a mouse mutant that may be a mouse version of FSHD.
Boston, MA
Please see High Protein and Exercise
Therapy (HPET) article on page 4
David C. Preston
Neuromuscular Service
Brigham & Women's Hosptial
75 Francis Street
Boston, Massachusetts 02115
Barbara E. Shapiro
Neurology Service
Massachusetts General Hospital
15 Parkman Street, Acc #835
Boston, Massachusetts 02114
Interests: Clinical and nutritional
Sao Paulo, Brazil
M. Rita Passos-Bueno
Departmento de Biologia
Instituto de Biociencias
Universidade de Sao Paulo
Sao Paulo, C.P. 11461
CEP 05422-970 S.P. Brazil
Interest(s): Clinical and occupational
Irvine, CA
Sara T. Winokur
Ulla Bengtsson
Rachelle Markovitch
John Wasmuth
Michael Altherr*
Department of Biological Chemistry
University of California, Irvine
Irvine, CA 92717
Interest(s): Molecular genetics
*Michael Altherr is currently with the Genomics and Structural Biology Group,
LANL, Los Alamos, NM
Manchester, England
London, England
Jane Hewitt
Robert Lyle
Lorraine Clark
Elizabeth M. Valleley
Laboratory of Human Molecular Genetics
Department of Cell and Structural Biology
3.239 Stopford Building
University of Manchester
Oxford Road
Manchester M13 3PT
England
Robert Williamson
Tracy Wright
Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Genetics
St. Mary's Hospital Medical School
Imperial College of Science, Tech., & Medicine
Norfolk Place
London, W21PG
England
Interest(s): Molecular genetics
Cardiff, England
Bristol, England
Peter Harper
Meena Upadhyaya
Institute of Medical Genetics
University of Wales College of Medicine
Heath Park
Cardiff CF4 4XN
England
Peter Lunt
Philip Jardine
Institute of Child Health
Bristol Royal Hospital for Sick Children
St. Michael's Hill
Bristol BS2 8BJ
England
Interest(s): Molecular genetics and clinical
Columbus, OH
Jerry Mendell
Department of Neurology
Ohio State University
Columbus, Ohio 43210
Interest(s): Clinical
Italy
L. Felicetti
Intituto de Biologia Cellulare, CNR
Interest(s): Molecular genetics
ST. Petersburg, Russia
Valery M. Kazakov
Department of Neurology
Pavlov's Medical Institute
L. Tolstoy Str. 6/8
197089 St. Petersburg
Russia
Interest(s): Clinical
Davis, CA
Please see Reasearch Paper on pages 13-16
Please see Fowler Receives Krusen Award article on page 27
M. Brewer
D.D. Kilmer
R. T. Abresch
S.G. Aitkens
G.T. Carter
W.M. Fowler
E.R. Johnson
C.M. McDonald
N.J. Wright
Research and Training Center on Neuromuscular Disease
Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation
University of California, Davis
TB 191
Davis, CA 95616-8665
and
National Institute on Disability & Rehabilitation Research
The research is being conducted by the Research and Training Center on
Neuromuscular Disease and the National Institute on Disability &
Rehabilitation Research.
Interest(s): Rehabilitation, Occupational and Clinical
FSH Office Updates
East Coast Office
As your executive director, it has been my pleasure to meet with you by phone,
mail and in person. The past months have been busy and fruitful for our
organization. We have met our 1994 budget through your memberships and
donations, and doubled our mailing list for information and networking
nationally. I have continued to follow up on your requests for resources,
groups, legislative initiatives and support.
Many of you have called, breaking through the isolation of being labeled with
FSHD, to speak to someone else with this problem. You often tell me of your
frustration with misinformation and misunderstanding, and your concerns about
family and jobs. You tell me that I am the first person with FSHD you have met
and express relief with the recognition of shared lifelong confusion which the
FSH Society single-mindedly works to solve.
We are looking forward to planning a national meeting in 1995 for our
membership, as well as expanding our networking activities. Your response to
our survey on bulletin boards, groups, meetings and research initiatives is
imperative so that we can carry out the activities you wish to support. I
welcome your calls and comments and look forward to greater strides in our
second year of advocacy.
--Carol A. Perez, M.Ed., C.R.C.
West Coast Office
The FSH Society is pleased with the events of the past several months. We
continue to successfully educate and inform the public including many
physicians, health providers and relevant governmental funding agencies. The
Public Health Services has recently awarded an NIH grant for FSHD research.
There are additional outstanding researchers committed to the study of FSHD,
and we anticipate success for those and others in obtaining needed support
through the Public Health Services. This resource, beyond the generous support
currently available from the Muscular Dystrophy Association, is very
important.
As you will note in this issue of the FSH Watch, the progress toward
understanding FSHD and its cause, and developing treatments is encouraging. The
Society will continue to apprise you of coming advances, and the West Coast
Office remains available for assistance with your calls and inquiries.
Thank you for your generosity in supporting our efforts. I hope that those of
you who have not yet joined will consider doing so in 1995. If there are those
of you with experience in fund raising (and I am certain there are), I would
ask that you consider offering your Society the benefits of your background and
expertise. Such activities guarantee our ability to provide current and future
services to many of you.
--Stephen J. Jacobsen, Ph.D.
Feedback . . .
Talk to Us!
The FSH Society board and counsel have recently discussed creation of
additional useful services and activities for its members. Please write us with
your opinion of the following considerations:
National Membership Conference
What are your thoughts regarding a national membership meeting in late 1995 or
early 1996? It would provide an opportunity for members and interested
individuals to meet and share information and views about many topics regarding
FSHD and future activities consistent with the Society's goals.
Included in the meeting would be an opportunity to receive information from
individuals of the health services and research community in a lecture and
question/answer format. The Society would organize and cover expenses for the
meeting itself, but could not reimburse you for your airfare or hotel
accommodations of a two-day event. We would very much appreciate a response
from those of you who are both interested and would intend to attend.
National Scientific Conference
There is very promising activity in both isolation and characterization of the
FSHD defect and FSHD treatment trials. Periodic meetings of professionals in
the medical and research communities and various governmental agencies are an
important part of this activity. The Society wishes to sponsor such a symposium
in early 1996. The Research & Education Fund, described below, would make
it possible for members to help the Society in this endeavor. We would very
much appreciate your comments. Would you wish to donate to the Fund for this
purpose?
Bulletin Board
The FSH Society can establish a computer bulletin board accessible by members
with a computer, modem and software services such an Internet, Prodigy,
Compuserve and America On-line. Do you have or have accesses to such services?
If so, are you interested in, and would you use, a bulletin board? Would you
like a format where information regarding FSHD issues (i.e., research and
clinical studies update, questions or general concern to FSHD individuals,
etc.) is available by computer? Would you be interested in a bulletin board for
conversational interchange among members?
Research & Education Fund
The FSH Society can begin a Research & Education Fund to specifically
promote and sustain productive activities related to basic and clinical FSHD
studies in the medical research community. Use of monies from such a fund would
be made on a case by case determination. Such activities would follow the
stated goals of the Society and be totally accountable to all of the
Society's donors and members. Activities supported by the Fund would
be independent of its other current activities, i.e., administrative,
legislative activities, newsletter, and support groups. Would you support and
contribute to such a fund?
Please write to us with your feedback on these issues to:
FSH Society
3 Westwood Road
Lexington, MA 02420
Dear FSH Society . . .
I suggest you settle on FSH as the style for the society in its newsletter and
correspondence use for our shared muscular disorder. It is confusing to read of
FSH, FSHMD, or the awkward FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular Dystrophy. Similarly,
decide whether to call this a rare or common disease!
--R.W.H., South Dennis, MA
Editor's Note: Our thanks to all of you who wrote to ask that we adopt a more
standardized way of referring to FSHD. We chose FSHD (FacioScapuloHumeral
Disease) because it becomes a term that includes the differing disorders
associated with FSH. We also chose to use "FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular
Dystrophy" when writing out the word to facilitate pronunciation and to
clarify that FSHD is a form of muscular dystrophy. We hope that this
standardization of terminology is helpful to our readers.
Current Happenings in FSHD Research
Two meetings have been held in the past year where information pertaining to
FSHD was discussed. The 8th International Congress on Neuromuscular Diseases
was held in Kyoto, Japan in July. During the course of that meeting, an
International Symposium on FSHD was held. The Kyoto symposium was organized by
Dr. Kiichi Arahata (National Institute of Neuroscience--NCNP, Tokyo,
Japan) and Dr. Theodore Munsat (Tufts University, Boston, MA).
In October 1994, the annual American Society of Human Genetics meeting was held
in Montreal, Canada. At the ASHG meeting, the Muscular Dystrophy Association
sponsored a workshop on FSHD. Both meetings were well attended by researchers
and clinicians from the international community working on FSHD.
Recently, a paper was published showing an association between a DNA deletion
and FSHD. The paper was presented at both meetings. One research team reported
that the size of this deletion is associated with age of onset and clinical
severity of FSHD. However, it is difficult to understand this result given the
great variability in FSHD--associated symptoms within families where all
affected members contain DNA deletions of the same size.
Researchers continue to search for the FSHD gene on chromosome 4. However, no
group has announced the identification of the FSHD gene. The search for the
FSHD gene is complicated by the presence of sequences in the FSHD gene region
that are also found on several other chromosomes. The research community has
acknowledged that this is a very difficult region of the chromosome to work
within and it presents many complex problems. However, all groups remain
cautiously optimistic, and the race to find the gene continues to be intensely
competitive.
Several research groups are actively searching for the FSHD gene by identifying
and studying genes that map near the FSHD associated deletions. They include:
Dr. Michael Altherr (Los Alamos National Laboratory), Dr. Denise Figlewicz
(University of Rochester), Dr. Rune Frantz (University of Leiden, The
Netherlands), Dr. Jane Hewitt (University of Manchester, U.K.), Dr. Kathy
Mathews (University of Iowa), Dr. Meena Upadhyaya (University of Cardiff,
U.K.), Dr. Kiichi Arahata (National Institute of Neuroscience--NCNP,
Tokyo, Japan), Dr. Sara Winokur (University of California, Irvine) and Dr.
Barbara Weiffenbach (Collaborative Research Division, Genome Therapeutics
Corporation, Waltham, MA).
Lastly, several research groups are pursuing clinical studies. Dr. Robert
Griggs and Dr. Rabi Tawil (University of Rochester), and Dr. Jerry Mendell are
conducting natural history studies on FSHD as well as drug therapy trials. Dr.
Shapiro (Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, MA) and Dr. Preston (Brigham
& Women's, Boston, MA) are conducting High Protein Diet and
Exercise Therapy (HPET) trials. Please see related article on this study found
on page 4.
Research Paper:
Impairment and Disability Profiles of Neuromuscular Diseases:
FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular Dystrophy
D.D. Kilmer, M.D.; R.T. Abresch; S.G. Aitkens; G.T. Carter, M.D.; W.M. Fowler,
Jr., M.D.; E.R. Johnson, M.D.; C.M. McDonald, M.D.; N.J. Wright,
RTC/Neuromuscular Diseases, Department of Physical Medicine &
Rehabilitation, University of California, Davis and National Inst. on
Disability & Rehabilitation Research
Editor's Note: We have placed this research paper in the center of the
newsletter so you may conveniently pull it out and save it for future
reference. Reprinted with permission.
FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular Dystrophy (FSHD) is one of several disorders
included in the FacioScapuloHumeral syndrome. This syndrome includes
individuals with facial involvement in spinal muscular atrophy and congenital
myopathy. FSHD can occur with or without inflammatory cells in the muscle (as
in polymyositis) and some cases are associated with Coat's disease
(deafness).
FSHD is a myopathy, usually slowly progressive, and inherited as a dominant
trait. It is a rare neuromuscular disease with an estimated prevalence between
10 to 20 cases per million individuals. While the characteristics are well
known (weakness of the face, shoulder and hip girdle, and anterior
compartmental muscles of the leg), description of these characteristics has
been primarily based on clinical observations, and there have not been any
studies using specific measurements to evaluate each characteristic in terms of
a natural history profile. In addition, there have been few, if any,
investigations of the incidence and description of some of the characteristics
such as contractures, spine deformity, pulmonary and cardiac function,
intellectual and cognitive function, and psychosocial adjustment.
The purpose of this study was to develop a comprehensive impairment and
disability profile for FSHD. Impairment was evaluated by measurements of
strength, contractures, spine deformity, cardiac and pulmonary function, and
intellectual capacity. Disability evaluations consisted of measures of mobility
and upper extremity function, cardiac and pulmonary disease, and psychosocial
adjustments.
Fifty-three individuals followed in a regional neuromuscular disease clinic for
1982-1992 were reviewed. Thirty-two were males and 21 were females. Average age
was 38 years with an average age of symptom onset of 16 years at the time of
the first clinic visit. Five individuals were nonambulatory, and age at loss of
ambulation averaged 33 years. Four were known to have died during the ten year
period with a mean age of death at 68 years. All participants from the clinic
did not receive all measurements so the individuals in each of the impairment
and disability profiles would be considered as samples of the larger clinic
population.
When appropriate, results were compared with able-bodied subjects (controls)
and/or established reference standards. The effect of age and disease duration
was evaluated by both one-time event (cross sectional) and longitudinal
analysis. In the former, the first measurement obtained on every subject was
plotted against years of age and disease duration. In the latter, each
measurement for each individual for a three or more year period of time was
analyzed for any age or disease duration effect.
Body Composition Profile
Anthropometric and body composition measurements were obtained in a sample of
14 individuals. Anthropometric measures of height, bisacromial and billiac
diameters, wrist and ankle circumferences, and chest depth were within normal
limits in the FSHD group when compared to gender and age matched control
subjects and reference standards. Weight and the circumferential diameter of
the forearm were also within normal limits. The calf (-7%), thigh (-10%), and
upper arm (-11%) circumferences were, however, significantly reduced in the
FSHD group indicating mild loss of musculature. Body fat, as evaluated by skin
fold thickness at five sites, was within normal limits. For all parameters,
there was no significant age or disease duration effect indicating that muscle
wasting was very slowly progressive.
Muscle Weakness Profile
Muscle strength was evaluated by both manual muscle testing (MMT) units and
quantitative measurements of strength. MMTs: MMTs were obtained in a sample of
22 individuals. Grading was on a 0-5 scale, in which 5 is normal for 34 muscle
groups. The total strength grade for all muscle groups combined was 3.7 MMT
units (complete range of motion against gravity plus minimal resistance from
the therapist). In cross-sectional one-time event analysis, there was a very
slow but significant rate of decline in mean total strength of -0.022 MMT units
per year of disease duration.
Average grades for clusters of muscle groups showed that the lower extremity
muscles were weaker than the upper extremity muscles; the proximal muscles
weaker than the distal muscles; extensor muscles weaker than flexor muscles;
and the ankle dorsiflexors weaker than the plantar flexors. In general, the
rate of strength decline was more rapid in the weaker muscle groups of the
lower extremities.
While the mean MMT grades and rates of decline of strength for the dominant and
non-dominant side muscle groups was the same, a combination of selected upper
extremity muscles were significantly weaker in the dominant upper extremity
muscles.
Two patterns of weakness appeared to be present. One group of individuals
showed greater weakness of the hip girdle muscles, while the other group had
greater weakness of the ankle muscles at the same point in time. The former was
more common. In addition, an early age of onset of less than 15 years was
associated with greater likelihood of more severe weakness. Individual
longitudinal measurements of a three or more year period were quite
heterogeneous showing worsening in some individuals and relative stability in
others.
Quantitative Measurements
of Strength
Quantitative measurements of the static (isometric) strength of the knee
flexors and extensors, elbow flexors and extensors, shoulder flexors and
extensors, neck flexors and extensors, hand grip, and pinch were obtained in 14
individuals with FSHD and compared to 90 gender and age-matched, able-bodied
subjects. The isometric strength of the muscles in FSHD individuals was reduced
between 36 and 68 percent for the various individual measures. In addition,
grip strength of FSHD individuals was significantly weaker than the control
group in the dominant but not the non-dominant limb. Measurements of the
dynamic (isokinetic concentric and eccentric) strengths of the knee flexors and
extensors and elbow flexors and extensors demonstrated a similar pattern with
average reductions of strength between 33 and 47 percent for the various
individual measures.
In summary, manual muscle testing indicated greater involvement of the proximal
musculature; although a subgroup showed early weakness of the ankle
dorsiflexors. Asymmetric upper extremity weakness was noted with greater
weakness of certain muscles in the dominant (most used) limb muscle groups.
Possible overwork weakness of the dominant limb also seemed to be present based
on grip strength being weaker in the dominant limb. As a group, weakness
appeared to progress very slowly, although certain individuals showed a more
rapid progression of weakness.
Limb Range of Motion
(ROM) Profile
ROM was measured in a sample of 22 individuals to evaluate contractures using
standard gonlometry. Measurements included shoulder abduction, elbow and wrist
extension, hip adduction for iliotibial band tightness, hip and knee extension
and ankle dorsiflexion. For all joints combined, the frequency and severity of
contractures were quite low. Although 42% had loss of ROM of 5 degrees or
greater at any joint, only 36% had loss of ROM of 20 degrees or more, and the
mean contracture index (CI - a product of the percentage of patients with
contractures x the maximal loss of ROM divided by 1,000) was only 0.63 (a high
CI would be greater than 1.0 and a low CI less than 0.5). Loss of ROM was most
frequent (25%) or severe (CI - 1.68) at the shoulder.
There was no significant age or disease duration effect on ROM. Therefore,
contractures were not a major characteristic of FSHD but, when occurring, were
most frequent at the shoulder. Contractures in all of the major neuromuscular
diseases is reviewed in the FOCUS section of the February 1994 RTC
newsletter.
Spine Deformity Profile
In a sample of 45 individuals with FSHD, only 16 (35%) had clinical evidence of
spine deformity. Of these, 9 (56%) had hyperlordosis (increased lumbar curve)
with or without scoliosis, most with a disease duration over 20 years. In those
who had spine X-rays, the spinal curve ranged from 5 to only 25 degrees. While
the lordosis increased with age and disease duration, there was no significant
progression of the scoliosis. Severe lordosis, therefore, appeared to be a
major characteristic of FSHD while the incidence of scoliosis was low and the
severity mild and relatively non-progressive.
Pulmonary Function and Restrictive Lung Disease
(RLD) Profile
Pulmonary function tests (PFT) were obtained in a sample of 23 individuals.
There was only mild impairment on routine (spirometric) PFTs with the group
mean for most parameters within normal reference standards. Eighty-two percent
vital capacity (VC) was less than 80% of the predicted in 48% of the
individuals (80% or above is considered normal), but only less than 50% in 13%
of the individuals (50% or less is considered to be severe involvement).
There was, however, greater impairment in the static airway pressures. Maximum
expiratory pressures (MEPs) were about 44% of normal while the maximum
inspiratory pressures (MIPs) were only 74% of normal. Since expiatory pressures
were more affected than inspiratory pressures, the MEP:MIP ratio was 1.1 which
is significantly less than the normal value of 1.8.
The results suggest that the expiatory muscles are more affected than the
inspiratory muscles in FSHD, resulting in only mildly abnormal spirometric PFTs
since the latter primarily reflect active inspiratory functions. There was no
significant age or disease duration effect on PFT measurements, while the
difference in mean percent VC between individuals with and without spine
deformity was statistically significant, this observation was not of clinical
importance since only 4% had a predicted percent VC below 51%.
Only 10 (22%) of 45 individuals in the study had significant pulmonary
complications such as pneumonia. There was no age or disease duration effect on
the frequency. All individuals with low predicted VCs had pulmonary
complications, and those with spine deformity had a 34% higher frequency of
pulmonary complications than those without deformity. No one had acute or
chronic respiratory failure requiring mechanical ventilation.
In summary, while there was evidence of restrictive lung disease (RLD) in half
of the sample population, only 4 individuals (17%) had moderate or severe RLD.
The relatively mild and essentially non-progressive impairment in pulmonary
function and the low frequency of respiratory complications indicates that RLD
is usually not a major problem in FSHD.
Cardiac Function and Cardiovascular Disease Profile
Electrocardiograms (ECGs) were obtained in a sample of 32 individuals. While 23
(77%) ECGs were reported as abnormal, most had minor findings. The highest
percent of abnormalities were bradycardia (56%), and abnormal Q-waves (40%),
and increased R/S ratio in lead V (28%). Since 69% of the abnormal ECGs
occurred in individuals with a disease duration greater than 15 years, there
appeared to be a disease duration effect. However, all of the ECG findings
cannot be attributed to neuromuscular disease since the age range extended to
78 years.
Fifteen (28%) of 53 individuals had a history of significant cardiovascular
complications such as chest pain, palpitations or dyspnea. There was no disease
duration effect, or correlation between complications and ECG abnormality.
Therefore, the clinical significance of the high percentage of abnormal ECGs is
unclear especially since most abnormalities were mild.
Intellectual and
Memory Function Profile
Scores on all neuropsychological tests in a sample of 13 adults were within
normal limits for intellectual, memory and cognitive function. Full scale IQ
was 105+14, and the percentage of individuals with low average full scale IQ
scores (<89) was only 9%. On the arithmetic subtests, 31% were in the
impaired range as compared to 15% for published norms. There was no significant
difference between verbal and performance IQ indicating the weakness did not
affect IQ. In those tested for three or more years, there was no change over
time indicating that there was no disease duration effect.
Psychosocial Adjustment
A group of 13 individuals with FSHD exhibited few neuropsychological symptoms.
Several subtests of the MMPI demonstrated higher percentages of abnormality
than normal, but these occurred in all neuromuscular diseases studied, and may
reflect problems applying standard neuropsychological tests to a physically
disabled population. Another scale of psychological function, the SPS, showed
46% of FSHD individuals having an elevated degree of hopelessness and 39%
having elevated levels of the hostility and negative self-evaluations
subscores. On the contrary, 31% scored high on the achievement through
independent subtest of the CPI, suggesting excellent function in this area.
Mobility and Extremity Function Profiles
Upper and lower extremity timed motor performance tests (TMP) and function
evaluation levels were obtained in 22 individuals. Functional grades consisted
of six levels of function for the upper extremities and 11 levels for the lower
extremities. On both scales, grade 1 was normal function. For the upper
extremities, 32% were grade 1, while 23% required elbow flexion in order to
raise the arms fully; 41% were only able to raise an 8 oz glass to the mouth
level, and 4% could not raise the glass to the mouth. In the lower extremities,
81% were able to walk or climb stairs without assistance or requiring aid of a
railing. Measuring the performance of timed motor performance tests, in general
it took 2-6 times longer for FSHD individuals to perform TMP tasks. This
demonstrates subtle increases in time required to perform functional activities
in these individuals which may not be evident without formal testing.
Adaptations to Exercise Training
A moderate resistance muscle strengthening exercise program was carried out
with two individuals having FSHD, using the same regimen described in the
Research Update Impairment and Disability Profile of Hereditary Motor Sensory
Neuropathy in the January 1993 RTC Newsletter. There was no difference noted
from the response described in that report, i.e., the exercise program had no
deleterious effect.
Summary
This natural history profile of FSHD demonstrates its clinical heterogeneity;
that is, affected individuals may be clinically impaired to a much greater
extent than previously described. Limb contractures were infrequent and mild,
and spine deformity primarily limited to hyperlordosis. There was a relatively
mild and essentially non-progressive impairment in pulmonary function and low
frequency of respiratory complications. Intellectual function was normal.
There was a slow but significant rate of decline of overall strength per year.
The lower extremity muscles were weaker than the upper extremity muscles,
proximal weaker than distal, and extensor muscles weaker than flexor muscles.
The rate of yearly strength decline was more rapid in the weaker muscle groups.
Muscle strength was weaker on the upper extremity dominant side with MMTs, and
quantitatively measured grip strength. The FSHD group was weaker than the
control group in the dominant, but not the non-dominant, side indicating the
possibility of overwork weakness. Two patterns of weakness appeared to occur.
Some individuals showed greater weakness of the hip girdle muscles while others
had greater weakness of the ankle muscles at the same point in time. Weakness
led to mild disability evident by reduced upper and lower extremity function
and slowed motor performance.
FSH Society Statement
FacioScapuloHumeral Muscual Dystrophy (FSHD) is a muscle disease with a
frequency in the population of between 4 and 10 per 100,000. The disease is
inheritable; the responsible gene is located on chromosome 4. The expression of
symptoms requires inheritance of the defective gene from only one affected
parent. An individual of either sex has a fifty percent chance of inheriting
the gene from that affected parent.
The disease pathology includes a progressive loss of skeletal muscle with a
usual pattern of initial noticeable weakness of facial, scapular and upper arm
muscles and subsequent developing weaknesses of other muscles of the torso and
lower limbs. Early facial weaknesses distinguish this disease from other
neuromuscular diseases that can be similar in appearance. The age of onset is
variable, as is the eventual extent and degree of muscle loss, but noticeable
muscle weaknesses are usually present by the age of twenty and are recognizable
in all but a small percentage of adults who carry the gene.
The prognosis includes both a loss of muscular strength that limits personal
and occupational activities of most FSHD individuals, and a loss of mobility in
perhaps twenty percent of the cases. Hearing loss and retinal abnormalities
associated with FSHD have been reported, but the frequency of these effects and
their relationship, if any, to the causative gene for the muscle defect are
uncertain.
The FacioScapuloHumeral Society (FSH Society) is an independent, non-profit and
tax-exempt U.S. corporation organized to address issues and needs specifically
related to FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular Dystrophy (FSHD). Papers certifying its
incorporation, bylaws and tax-exempt status are deposited at the
corporation's east and west coast offices and the office of its
General Counsel in Washington, D.C.
Q & A
The FSH Society establishes our FSHD information column in this edition.
Questions you ask will be answered by professionals knowledgeable in
FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular Dystrophy (FSHD), also known as Landouzy-Dejerine
muscular dystrophy. A collection of responses will be updated and published in
an information booklet. Please address your FSHD questions in writing to:
Stephen J. Jacobsen, Ph.D., FSH Society, Inc., West Coast Office, 1507 Traske
Road, Encinitas, CA 92024.
Q. Does FSHD affect the heart muscle?
A.Unlike some of the other muscular dystrophies, such as Duchenne's
muscular dystrophy, the heart muscle is not involved in FacioScapuloHumeral
Muscular Dystrophy (FSHD). The life span and quality of life in individuals
with FSHD is not affected by heart muscle involvement.
There are, oddly enough, problems that can occur with the electrical system in
the heart. Older studies have shown rare cases of atrial standstill in patients
with FSHD. Atrial standstill is a phenomenon in which the two small chambers of
the heart are motionless. Since these chambers do not contribute more than 10%
to the effectiveness of the heart, patients with this disorder are unaware that
they have this problem. These older studies may be misleading, though, because
they probably included individuals with Emery-Dreifuss Muscular Dystrophy, a
more recently recognized muscular dystrophy that is similar to FSHD but also
has contractures of the elbow and achilles tendons.
A more recent study, that was published in 1990, in which 30 individuals with
FSHD were studied by cardiac cauterization using electrical catheters, showed
no atrial standstill. They did demonstrate that atrial fibrillation, a
condition in which the two small chambers of the heart fibrillate causing an
irregular heart beat, was more easily induced in patients with FSHD than in
unaffected individuals. They concluded that FSHD is probably not associated
with atrial standstill, but may have a tendency towards atrial fibrillation. In
clinical studies, atrial fibrillation has not been seen, and what occurs in the
laboratory does not always reflect real life.
In an unpublished study from the University of California, Davis, researchers
found frequent abnormalities on the electrocardiogram (ECG). The most common
abnormality was a slow heart rate. They also found slowed electrical conduction
through the heart. This slowed conduction was also demonstrated in the 30
patients in the 1990 study mentioned earlier. The researchers at Davis also
found that 28% of the patients studied complained of palpitations, chest pain,
or shortness of breath. The significance of these complaints is unknown as
heart disease is, in general, not a problem in FSHD, and the electrical
problems found on ECG are unlikely to cause these complaints.
In summary, FSHD is associated with electrical abnormalities which are usually
benign. It is not associated with muscle failure and individuals can expect to
live their lives free of heart disease.
--William R. Lewis, III, M.D., Cardiologist, Cardiovascular Medicine,
School of Medicine, University of California, Davis, is an FSH Society board
member and member of the Scientific Advisory Board of the FSH Society.
Q.How successful is Scapula Fixation (shoulder)?
A.Adults with FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular Dystrophy often ask about the
advisability of having a surgical procedure performed where the scapula is
fixated to the posterior rib cage (scapulothoracic arthrodesis). This procedure
can position the shoulder in such a way that the upper arm is more functional.
The surgery is not always successful, however, and carries some risks with it
including the possibility of a nerve injury, restricted shoulder motion, and
even a punctured lung. More than half of the patients that undergo this
procedure are pleased with the results, but not every orthopedic surgeon is
comfortable performing this procedure.
Accordingly, it is best to "shop" for surgical opinions among the
orthopedic surgeons within your community. No one surgeon nor surgical team in
North America actually specializes in this procedure. For those interested in
reading further, consider the article published by Dr. Wilton Bunch and Dr.
Irwin Siegel in The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery in March, 1993.
--Paul Schultz, M.D., Neurologist, Director of Muscle Disease Clinic,
Children's Hospital, San Diego, California, is an FSH Society board
member and
Chairman of the Scientific Advisory Board of the FSH Society, Inc.
Washington Update
Congress finished its session frustrated over the lack of any progress on the
major issue on its agenda--health care reform. The frustration was
especially high because the elections are unlikely to clarify further the
public's wishes regarding restructuring the health care delivery
system. In addition, the prospect of significant Republican gains and possible
control of either the House or Senate (or both) has dampened the hopes of
advocates of universal coverage.
Before leaving town, Congress did pass the appropriations for the National
Institutes of Health (NIH). The National Institute on Neurological Disorders
and Stroke (NINDS) received a 3.2% increase which was about the average
increase for NIH as a whole. This low increase, barely keeping pace with the
effects of inflation, reflect the continuing struggle to lower federal
spending. Funding for NIH comes out of "discretionary spending"
which is controlled annually by Congressional appropriations as opposed to
"entitlement spending" which is set by law. It is not subject to
annual control, and regarded as politically dangerous to try to change.
The next fiscal year (1996) may look better. The NIH budget has been submitted
to the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) which drafts the
President's budget. The Department of Health and Human Services (of
which NIH is a part) is recommending a 4.2% increase for NIH. In addition, it
is recommending an additional $16 million for Decade of the Brain research,
similar to special initiatives for AIDS and breast cancer. This is the kind of
special initiative that advocates for the Decade of the Brain have been
seeking.
The National Coalition for Research in Neurological Disorders (NCR), of which
the FSH Society is a member, is calling on all members to write President
Clinton urging that his budget include the special initiative on brain research
but at a level of $46 million, not $16 million to reflect the far greater
numbers of individuals with brain disorders as opposed to AIDS or breast
cancer.
--R. Morgan Downey,
FSH Society General Counsel
Research Bibliography
1993 n n n
Tawil R, Storvick D, Feasby TE, Weiffenbach B, Griggs RC, (1993). Extreme
variability of expression in monozygotic twins with FSH muscular dystrophy.
Neurology 43(1):345-48.
Wevers CW, Brouwer OF, Padberg GW, Nijboer ID, (1993). Job perspectives in
facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy. Disabil Rehabil 15(1):24-8 93160515.
Brouwer OF, Wijmenga C, Frants RR, Padberg GW, (1993). Facioscapulohumeral
muscular dystrophy: the impact of genetic research. Clin Neurol Neurosurg
95(1):9-21.
Bunch WH, Siegel IM, (1993). Scapulothoracic arthrodesis in
facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy. Review of seventeen procedures with
three to twenty-one year follow-up. J Bone Joint Surg Am 75(3):372-6.
Haraguchi Y, Chung AB, Torroni A, Stepien G, Shoffner JM, Wasmuth JJ,
Costigan DA, Polak M, Altherr MR, Winokur ST, et al, (1993). Genetic mapping
of human heart-skeletal muscle adenine nucleotide translocator and its
relationship to the facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy locus. Genomics
16(2):479-85.
Passos-Bueno MR, Wijmenga C, Takata RE, Marie SK, Vainzof M, Pavanello RC,
Hewitt JE, Bakker E, Carvalho A, Akiyama J, et al, (1993). No evidence of
genetic heterogeneity in Brazilian facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy
families (FSHD) with 4q markers. Hum Mol Genet 2(5):557-62.
Weiffenbach B, Dubois J, Storvick D, Tawil R, Jacobsen SJ, Gilbert J,
Wijmenga C, Mendell JR, Winokur S, Altherr MR, et al, (1993). Mapping the
facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy gene is complicated by chromosome 4q35
recombination events. Nat Genet 4(2):165-9.
Eggers S, Passos-Bueno MR, Zatz M, (1993). Facioscapulohumeral muscular
dystrophy: aspects of genetic counseling, acceptance of preclinical diagnosis,
and fitness. J Med Genet 30(7):589-92.
Upadhyaya M, Jardine P, Maynard J, Farnham J, Sarfarazi M, Wijmenga C,
Hewitt JE, Frants R, Harper PS, Lunt PW, (1993). Molecular analysis of
British facioscapulohumeral dystrophy families for 4q DNA rearrangements. Hum
Mol Genet 2(7):981-7.
Gilbert JR, Stajich JM, Wall S, Carter SC, Qiu H, Vance JM, Stewart CS,
Speer MC, Pufky J, Yamaoka LH, et al, (1993). Evidence for heterogeneity in
facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD). Am J Hum Genet 53(2):401-8.
Wijmenga C, Winokur ST, Padberg GW, Skraastad MI, Altherr MR, Wasmuth JJ,
Murray JC, Hofker MH, Frants RR, (1993). The human skeletal muscle adenine
nucleotide translocator gene maps to chromosome 4q35 in the region of the
facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy locus. Hum Genet 92(2):198-203.
Jardine P, Jones M, Tyfield L, Upadhyaya M, Lunt P, (1993). De novo DNA
rearrangement in atypical facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy [letter] In:
Clin Genet 44(3):167.
Wijmenga C, Wright TJ, Baan MJ, Padberg GW, Williamson R, van Ommen G-JB,
Hewitt JE, Hofker MH, Frants RR, (1993). Physical mapping and YAC-cloning
connects four genetically distinct 4qter loci (D4S163, D4S139, D4F35S1 and
D4F104S1) in the FSHD gene-region. Hum Mol Genet 2(10):1667-72.
Winokur ST, Schutte B, Weiffenbach B, Washington SS, McElligott D,
Chakravarti A, Wasmuth JH, Altherr MR, (1993). A radiation hybrid map of 15
loci on the distal long arm of chromosome 4, the region containing the gene
responsible for facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD). Am J Hum Genet
53(4):874-80.
Wright TJ, Wijmenga C, Clark LN, Frants RR, Williamson R, Hewitt JE,
(1993). Fine mapping of the FSHD gene region orientates the rearranged fragment
detected by the probe p13E-11. Hum Mol Genet 2(10):1673-78.
Griggs RC, Tawil R, Storvick D, Mendell JR, Altherr MR, (1993). Genetics of
facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy: new mutations in sporadic cases.
Neurology 43(11):2369-72.
Jakab E, Gledhill RB, (1993). Simplified technique for scapulocostal fusion in
facioscapulohumeral dystrophy. In: J Pediatr Orthop 13(6):749-51.
Tawil R, Storvick D, Weiffenbach B, Altherr MR, Feasby TE, Griggs RC,
(1993). Chromosome 4q DNA Rearrangement in Monozygotic Twins Discordant for
Facioscapulohumeral Muscular Dystrophy Human Mutations 2:492-94.
1994 n n n
Personius KE, Pandya S, King WM, Tawil R, (1994). McDermott MP
FacioScapuloHumeral dystrophy natural history study: standardization of testing
procedures and reliability of measurements. The FSH DY Group. Phys Ther
74(3):253-63.
Brouwer OF, Padberg GW, Wijmenga C, Frants RR, (1994). FacioScapuloHumeral
muscular dystrophy in early childhood. Arch Neurol 51(4):387-94.
Tawil R, McDermott MP, Mendell JR, Kissel J, Griggs RC, (1994).
FacioScapuloHumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD): design of natural history study
and results of baseline testing. FSH-DY Group. Neurology 44(3 Pt1):442-6.
Weiffenbach B, Dubois J, Manning S, Ma NS, Schutte BC, Winokur ST, Altherr MR,
Jacobsen SJ, Stanton VP Jr., Yokoyama K, et al, (1994). YAC contigs for 4q35 in
the region of the facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) gene. Genomics
19(3):532-41.
Wijmenga C, van Deutekom JC, Hewitt JE, Padberg GW, van Ommen GJ, Hofker MH,
Frants RR, (1994). Pulsed-field gel electrophoresis of the D4F104S1 locus
reveals the size and the parental origin of the facioscapulohumeral muscular
dystrophy (FSHD)-associated deletions. Genomics 19(1):21-6.
Masuda Y, Hayashi M, Obara H, (1994). [Sevoflurane anesthesia for a patient
with facioscapulohumeral muscle dystrophy] Masui 43(4):580-3 (Published in
Japanese).
Lunt PW, (1994) Report of the sixth International Workshop on
FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular Dystrophy: San Francisco, 11 November 1992; and
current guidelines for clinical application of DNA rearrangements at locus
D4S810. Muscular Dystrophy Group of America. Neuromuscul Disord 4(1):83-6.
Deidda GC, Cacurri S, La Cesa I, Scoppetta C, Felicetti L, (1994). 4q35
molecular probes for the diagnosis and genetic counseling of
facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy [letter] Ann Neurol 36(1):117-8.
Winokur ST, Bengtsson U, Feddersen J, Mathews KD, Weiffenbach B, Bailey H,
Markovich RP, Murray JC, Wasmuth JJ, Altherr MR, et al, (1994). The DNA
rearrangement associated with facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy involves a
heterochromatin-associated repetitive element: implications for a role of
chromatin structure in the pathogenesis of the disease. Chromosome Res
2(3):225-34.
Hewitt JE, Lyle R, Clark LN, Valleley EM, Wright TJ, Wijmenga C, van Deutekom
JCT, Francis F, Sharpe PT, Hofker M, Frants RR, and Williamson R, (1994).
Analysis of the tandem repeat locus D4Z4 associated with facioscapulohumeral
muscular dystrophy. Hum Mol Genet 3(8) 1287-1295.
Bengtsson U, Altherr MR, Wasmuth JJ, Winokur ST, (1994). High resolution
fruorescence In Situ hybridization to linearly extended DNA visually maps a
tandem repeat associated with facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy
immediately adjacent to the telomere of 4q. Hum Mol Genet 3(11) 1801-1806.
Support Groups
FSHD Groups Welcome New Members
The New England FSHD Support Group, the Mid Atlantic FSHD Support Group and the
New York FSHD Support Group are currently the only groups in the United States
offering the unique opportunity to meet others and share information and
support on FSHD issues. Meetings are generally held every other month on Sunday
afternoons covering topics specific to FSHD. Groups meet in accessible
locations.The groups are fortunate to have leading researchers and clinicians
available to present the current genetic and clinical information. Experts
address nutrition, exercise and coping strategies specific to FSHD.
Individuals, family members and professionals concerned with FSHD are welcome
to attend.
Since 1989, Carol Perez has facilitated the New England FSHD Support Group. The
New England group covers Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire,
Rhode Island and Vermont, and meets in Woburn, MA.
Since 1990, Karen Johnsen has led the Mid Atlantic FSHD Support Group in Bowie,
MD. The Mid Atlantic group includes Maryland, Virginia, Washington, DC,
Delaware and Pennsylvania. New members are always welcome to join the group and
participate in these informational meetings.
With pleasure, we announce the formation of the New York FSHD Support Group.
The New York group began meeting in September, 1994, with members coming from
New York, New Jersey and Connecticut. They welcome anyone who wishes to attend
from any area. Under the leadership of Marilyn Meisel, they meet in Queens, New
York. Marilyn Meisel is a member of the family that founded the Muscular
Dystrophy Association and brings an interesting historical perspective to our
organization.
The Pennsylvania FSHD Support Group will begin meeting soon under the
leadership of Renae Beeker. Renae welcomes your calls and invites you to join
her in planning a schedule of meetings and agendas.
If you have any questions about the Groups, please feel free to contact the
following:
Mid Atlantic FSHD Support Group:Karen Johnsen12203 Foxhill LaneBowie, MD
20715Phone: (301) 262-0701.
The group is finishing a compilation of less well documented symptoms to aid
physicians with earlier and easier diagnosis and treatment of FSHD. Contact
Karen Johnsen for a schedule of meetings.
New England FSHD Support Group:Carol A. Perez
3 Westwood RoadLexington, MA 02420Phone: (617) 860-0501
Group meeting dates are December 4, 1994, February 12, 1995, April 2, 1995 and
June 4, 1995, at the Days Inn, 19 Commerce Way, Woburn, MA from 1 to 3:30
p.m.
At the October 1994 meeting, Connie Roberts, Manager of Nutrition Services at
Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, presented a program on nutrition
and FSHD.
New York FSHD Support Group:Marilyn MeiselFresh Meadows, New YorkPhone:
(718) 357-5079
The group met on November 13, 1994, to plan a schedule and agenda. Call Marilyn
Meisel for future dates.
At the September meeting, Carol A. Perez, Coordinator, FSH Society,
participated to provide information and updates on FSHD issues.
Pennsylvania FSHD Support Group:Renae BeekerHanover, PAPhone: (717)
632-4803
Call Renae Beeker for meeting date and location.
Note:
Please call Carol Perez, FSH Society Executive Director, East Coast Office,
(617) 860-0501, with any questions or interest in forming local groups for FSHD
as well as a network for Infantile FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular Dystrophy
(IFSHD). To preserve confidentiality, the FSH Society will contact members and
inform them of groups in their areas. We have requests to form groups in San
Diego, San Francisco and Los Angeles, CA; Denver, CO; New Orleans, LA; Kansas
City, MO and to set up a network for IFSHD. Information about support groups
and networks is published in the FSH Watch.
Network for IFSHD (Infantile FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular Dystrophy)
The Society wishes to form a national network for individuals and families
concerned with Infantile FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular Dystrophy. We have had
many requests for a network to address the specific concerns and needs of
IFSHD. Please call Carol A. Perez at (617)860-0501 or write to the FSH Society
at 3 Westwood Road, Lexington, MA 02420, for information if you wish to
participate in a telephone network and/or pen pal group.
International FSHD Group Updates
As of this edition, the FSH Society has links to FSHD Groups in England, France
and the Netherlands. The Coordinators for these groups and updates on their
activities are listed below. The French and Dutch Coordinators are fluent in
English.
England:
Mr. Robin Brown
FSHMD Support Group
1 Hobart Close
Whetstone
London
N20 OTT
England
Phone: 081 361 0089
Update: This group has a brochure, Twenty Questions, about FSHD by Dr. Peter
Lunt. The FSH Society has permission to copy and distribute this pamphlet. To
receive a copy, please send a self addressed stamped envelope with your request
to the East Coast Office of the FSH Society.
France:
Ms. Catherine Rouslin
16, Rue du Parc Royal
75003 Paris, France
Phone: (H) 42744574
(W) 40465102
Update: This group is establishing a cell bank and FSHD study as well as
completing a survey of medical and health issues of individuals with FSHD in
France.
Netherlands:
Mr. Albert Gielis
C. Beerninckstraat 102
3641 DE Mijdrecht
Netherlands
Phone: (H) 31 2979 83530
Update: The Netherlands group has published a profile on FSHD in Dutch.
Presently, the group is assessing its structure and organization to better
respond to the needs of individuals with FSHD.
Letter from the FacioScapuloHumeral Society, Inc. to the
International Symposium on FSHD held at Kyoto on July 10, 1994
FSH Society Addresses Kyoto Symposium
The FacioScapuloHumeral Society, Inc. (FSH Society) would like to congratulate
Kiichi Arahata, M.D., Theodore Munsat, M.D. and their colleagues on developing
an impressive program and symposium on the Clinical and Molecular Genetic
Aspects of FacioScapuloHumeral Muscular Dystrophy. Especially noteworthy is the
relevance of the material being presented, and the international character of
the symposium.
The FSH Society has the greatest respect and admiration for the researchers and
clinicians involved with FSHD, and realizes the professional and personal
implications of such an undertaking and that it is an arduous journey. Living
with FSHD is also a long, hard journey. The FSH Society offers the members of
the international community working on FSHD its cooperation and access to its
international network. FSH Muscular Dystrophy is a disease with no ego and no
formidable competition unless we all work together by sharing and cooperating
whenever and wherever possible.
The FSH Society is the only organization whose sole purpose is to serve the
FSHD community. Its international networking has brought together more than
eight hundred families committed to working together. Created because of the
need for a comprehensive resource for FSHD individuals and families, the
purposes of the organization are:
1. to create a clearinghouse for information on the FSHD disorder, and drugs
and devices for the treatment of same, and to foster communication among
individuals, families, caregivers, charitable organizations, government
agencies, industry, scientific researchers, academic institutions, and
interested individuals;
2. to accumulate and disseminate information about FSHD;
3. to encourage and promote increased scientific and clinical research and
development on the causes, alleviation of suffering and the cure of FSHD,
including without limitation, the promotion of research and development for the
treatment of FSHD for which funding may not otherwise be generally available;
4. to solicit grants and contributions from private foundations, the
pharmaceutical industry and others to support such research and development;
5. to make grants and awards to qualified applicants so that such applicants
may accomplish such research and development;
6. to act as a liaison among consumers, and government and industry
concerning research and development with respect to drugs and devices for
FSHD;
7. to represent individuals and families with FSHD not otherwise represented
by effective organizations, and to work cooperatively and collegially with
related organizations, including but not limited to the Muscular Dystrophy
Association and the National Organization of Rare Disorders; and
8. to educate the general public, relevant governmental bodies, and the
medical profession about the existence, diagnosis and treatment of the FSHD
disorder, a disease for which funding for research and development concerning
diagnosis and treatment may not be generally available.
The Society invites contact from any interested individuals, families,
physicians, caregivers, charitable organizations, government agencies,
industry, scientific researchers and academic institutions.
Individuals who have FSHD are life long survivors of the severe trauma and
tension of FSHD. They cope with the continuing, unrelenting and unending loss
caused by FSHD from the first second, into the first minute, hour, day, week,
over the months and through the years. Not for a moment is there a reprieve
from continual loss of physical ability; not for a moment is there a time to
mourn; not for a moment is there relief from the physical and mental pain that
is a result of this disease. They wake up every morning to the reality that
there is no known treatment and no known cause for this disease.
FSHD insidiously and systematically deprives a person of childhood,
adolescence, and the full range of choices in life. FSHD affects the way you
walk, the way you dress, the way you work, the way you wash, the way you sleep,
the way you relate, the way you parent, the way you love, the way and where you
live and the way people perceive and treat you. You cannot smile, hold a baby
in your arms, close your eyes to sleep, run or walk on the beach, or climb
stairs. Every day brings the awareness of the things one may not be able to do
tomorrow. This is the reality for the tens of thousands of people living with
FSHD.
The FSH Society gratefully acknowledges the importance of this symposium and
the opportunity to offer its resources to you. The FSH Society joins in this
process to enhance your endeavors and provide the patient perspective as well
as its network with individuals and families.
The FSH Society wishes to especially acknowledge Kiichi Arahata, M.D. for
inviting our participation and Theodore Munsat, M.D. who accepted the
responsibility of representing the FSH Society at this Symposium.
--Daniel P. Perez, President, FSH Society
Attention Members!
We are looking for members who would be willing to contact congressmen when
issues relating to the National Coalition for Research in Neurological
Disorders (NCR) come up before the various committees. If you would like to
receive information from NCR, please contact the FSH Society at 3 Westwood
Road, Lexington, MA 02420. The FSH Society is a member of NCR.
Senate Appropriations Committee
Subcommittee on Labor, Health and Human Services, Education
RepresentativePartyStateDC Phone
Tom Harkin, ChairmanDIowa202-224-3254
Christopher S. BondRMissouri202-224-5721
Dale BumpersDArkansas202-224-4843
Robert C. ByrdDWest Virginia202-224-3954
Thad CochranRMississippi202-224-5054
Slade GortonRWashington202-224-3441
Mark O. HatfieldROregon202-224-3753
Ernest F. HollingsDSouth Carolina202-224-6121
Daniel K. InouyeDHawaii202-224-3934
Herbert KohlDWisconsin202-224-5653
Connie MackRFlorida202-224-5274
Patty MurrayDWashington202-224-2621
Harry ReidDNevada202-224-3542
Arlen Specter, RankingRPennsylvania202-224-4254
Ted StevensRAlaska202-224-3004
House of Representatives Appropriations Committee
Subcommittee on Labor, Health and Human Services, Education
RepresentativePartyDistrictStateDC Phone
Neal Smith, ChairmanD4Iowa202-225-4426
Helen Delich BentleyR2Maryland202-225-3061
Henry BonillaR23Texas202-225-4511
Rosa L. DeLauroD3Connecticut202-225-3661
Steny H. HoyerD5Maryland202-225-4131
David R. ObeyD7Wisconsin202-225-3665
Nancy PelosiD8California202-225-4965
John E. Porter, RankingR